By John Yeld• 13 March 2021
Verlorenvlei on the West Coast is among the brightest of the 26 natural gems in South Africa’s rich crown of globally significant wetlands. (Photo: John Yeld)
There’s no argument that the Verlorenvlei wetland on the West Coast is an ecologically significant place – but how the catchment area is managed is at the heart of a row between conservationists and farmers.
Lonely but lovely Verlorenvlei on the West Coast is among the brightest of the 26 natural gems in South Africa’s rich crown of globally significant wetlands.
This spectacular vlei is a designated Ramsar site under a 1971 international treaty for the conservation and sustainable use of wetlands – arguably the most threatened of all natural ecosystems.
Technically, Verlorenvlei is defined as a partially closed coastal estuarine lake and marsh system rather than as a conventional wetland. But it was proclaimed as Ramsar site number 525 on 28 June 1991 under the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat (usually shortened to the Convention on Wetlands).
Stretching between the villages of Elands Bay and Redelinghuys about 25km south of Lambert’s Bay, Verlorenvlei is also listed by BirdLife International as an important bird and biodiversity area – a place of international significance for the conservation of birds and other biodiversity. It supports at least 189 bird species, of which 75 are waterbirds. The vlei occasionally hosts more than 4,000 birds and the highest number recorded in a single count was 11,891.
Trouble is, the 13.5km-long Verlorenvlei has been drying up over several years and, currently, the huge 1,400ha Ramsar vlei area is little more than a massive dust bowl.
A satellite image of Verlorenvlei on the Ramsar Convention’s website.
Gradual desiccation
One of South Africa’s few coastal freshwater lakes and among the most important estuarine systems in the Western Cape, the Verlorenvlei system lies in a winter rainfall area. If sufficient rain falls in the catchment, the vlei fills and sometimes overflows into the sea through its estuary in Elands Bay. Normally, it has an average depth of about 3m and a maximum depth of around 4.5m during the wet season. In summer, it gradually desiccates as part of its natural cycle.
“Generally the lake never dries up completely although, in very dry years, the water level can become extremely low,” BirdLife South Africa reports.
But four years ago, on 24 October 2017, the Department of Human Settlements, Water and Sanitation’s water meter on a jetty extending into the vlei registered zero – and, according to the Friends of Verlorenvlei conservation group, it has remained there.
The little surface water in the vlei became so saline as to be unusable. When World Wetlands Day was celebrated on 2 February, just a few small open patches of water remained.
The Friends group, which has been arguing for formal protected status for Verlorenvlei for many years, has initiated a campaign to raise awareness about the vlei and tackle what it sees as major problem areas, particularly excessive abstraction for agriculture.
“Over the past four decades, the greater catchment of the vlei has been plundered via untrammelled abstraction of ground and containment of surface water. It will be up to civil society to fight and win. If we fail, no more surface water will reach the vlei,” says Felicity Strange, group secretary of the Friends group.
The Friends group’s concerns are not fully shared by CapeNature, the Western Cape’s conservation authority and nominal manager of the state-owned vlei. The organisation ascribes the vlei’s desiccated appearance to a natural occurrence: the recent major drought in the province.
According to a specialist freshwater impact assessment of the dam project undertaken by Somerset West consultants as part of the section 24G application, the dam is an ‘off-channel’ structure filled via a pipeline from the Krom Antonies River and from existing boreholes. (Photo: John Yeld)
“We’ve just come through a four- to five- year drought that was quite severe, but that’s part of the natural cycle for estuarine lakes,” says Pierre de Villiers, CapeNature’s senior manager: marine and coasts operations. “We are in an extreme time and people are getting pretty emotional. I do understand that. But the vlei is not in a bad state. It looks bad but it has been just as dry two or three times previously that I can remember. But I’m not brushing off people’s concerns. If there’s a challenge, we will deal with it.”
CapeNature acknowledges that a decade-old study of the vlei is past its sell-by date and a new water reserve study has been commissioned. De Villiers says this study will be key to future effective management of Verlorenvlei by assessing current flows in the catchment and required flows to maintain the ecological integrity of the system.
“That will be our blueprint going forward to balance the various water uses and requirements.” The results of the reserve study are unlikely to be available in the short term.
De Villiers notes that both potato farmers and citrus growers in the region stand accused of excessive water use, but suggests such accusations are unwarranted. While agreeing that their irrigation methods look bad, he says a study has shown that potato farmers’ use of deep groundwater from boreholes doesn’t affect the shallow vlei, which has a clay lining, while citrus growers’ use of micro-irrigation techniques and shade cloth has reduced water consumption.
Despite such reassurances, it’s clear that problems remain.
When World Wetlands Day was celebrated on 2 February, just a few small open patches of water remained. (Photo: John Yeld)
Verlorenvlei’s catchment covers about 1,890km² and comprises four main tributaries. Arguably the most important of these is the Krom Antonies River, rising in the Piketberg mountains in the south and draining the rich Moutonshoek valley farming area. BirdLife SA says key threats to Verlorenvlei and its biodiversity include increasing water abstraction and agricultural intensification.
So it’s not surprising that an application by a Redelinghuys farm company for post facto condonation of its illegally constructed farm dam within the Verlorenvlei catchment is under close scrutiny from locals. The company’s stated intention to more than quadruple the size of the dam has raised the ire of the Friends of Verlorenvlei group.
In October last year, Piekenierskloof Vrugte submitted a Section 24G application in terms of the National Environmental Management Act for the rectification of the unlawful clearance of vegetation and enlargement of the Namaquasfontein Skool Dam on its farm. The dam is in the catchment of the Krom Antonies River, several unnamed tributaries of which run through the farm.
The application was made to the provincial environmental authorities because the R4.1-million dam had been upgraded without the required environmental approvals.
It involves the rectification of the 2017 phase one enlargement of the dam, from an original 1,000m³ to its current 47,000m³, with a 6.2m-high wall. It also involves a 250mm diameter pipeline, about 1.8km long, extending from the Krom Antonies River as well as two minor river crossings and a river abstraction point. The farm owner further proposes a phase two enlargement of the dam to a storage capacity of 200,000m³ behind an 11.5m-high wall.
The already enlarged Namaquasfontein Skool Dam. (Photo: John Yeld)
According to a specialist freshwater impact assessment of the dam project undertaken by Somerset West consultants as part of the section 24G application, the dam is an “off-channel” structure filled via a pipeline from the Krom Antonies River and from existing boreholes.
They note that in terms of guidelines to safeguard South Africa’s biodiversity, the river has been mapped as an aquatic critical biodiversity area while its tributaries are ecological support areas. Also, the entire Krom Antonies subcatchment has been mapped as a fish support area, while its associated wetland is a natural freshwater ecosystem priority area wetland.
Ecological status
The specialists point out that the ecological status of the Krom Antonies River in its reach at Namaquasfontein farm is “moderately to largely modified”, with the main impacts largely caused by land-use activities, as well as the upstream land and water use.
They conclude that the impact of the enlarged Namaquasfontein Skool Dam and its further enlargement will pose only a “moderate” risk to the Krom Antonies River system, provided mitigation measures are applied: “There is no reason why the existing and proposed activities should not be approved from an aquatic ecosystem point of view. This is provided that the recommended mitigation measures are implemented.”
The overall view of the environmental consultants managing the Section 24G application is that construction of the dam “does not have any unacceptable negative impacts on the biophysical and socioeconomic environments, and is supported by the freshwater, botanical and heritage specialists”.
The Friends of Verlorenvlei group is formally objecting to the application, in particular to the proposed expansion of the dam. It has slammed the absence of any consideration of the ecological impact on the bigger Verlorenvlei picture.
Stretching between the villages of Elands Bay and Redelinghuys about 25km south of Lambert’s Bay, Verlorenvlei is also listed by BirdLife International as an important bird and biodiversity area. (Photo: John Yeld)
“In the 21st year of the 21st century when global fresh water scarcity is widely acknowledged, it’s hard to believe that environmental consultants and their associated experts are so ignorant of the implications of rampant water abstraction and containment in the Greater Verlorenvlei Catchment,” says Nick Taylor, acting chair of the Friends group.
The application is still undergoing a public participation process and updated assessment documentation will be released for review and comment, probably this month.
As part of the application process, the provincial environmental authorities will levy an “administrative” fine on Piekeniers- kloof Vrugte before it takes any decision on whether to condone the illegal dam. Section 24G fines can be substantial: as high as R5-million or 10 years in jail, or both.
De Villiers says CapeNature does not support any extension to the Namaquasfontein Skool Dam or any increased water abstraction from the Verlorenvlei catchment before the water reserve study has been completed. DM168
West Coast’s Verlorenvlei: What’s lost when a wetland dries up?
Information and Discussions on Endangered Ecosystems
- Lisbeth
- Site Admin
- Posts: 67843
- Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:31 pm
- Country: Switzerland
- Location: Lugano
- Contact:
West Coast’s Verlorenvlei: What’s lost when a wetland dries up?
"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world." Nelson Mandela
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
The desire for equality must never exceed the demands of knowledge
Return to “Endangered Ecosystems”
Jump to
- Africa Wild Board Information
- ↳ Forum Information
- ↳ Africa Wild Forum Information
- ↳ Benefits for Africa Wild Members
- ↳ Questions
- ↳ Suggestions
- Conservation and Management Issues of Concern
- ↳ Rhino Management and Poaching
- ↳ Elephant Management and Poaching
- ↳ General Poaching
- ↳ Developments and Commercialisation in National Parks
- ↳ Proposed Developments in National Parks
- ↳ General Hotel Discussions, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Skukuza Hotel, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Re-zoning, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Developments, KNP
- ↳ Proposed Developments, KTP
- ↳ Sporting (and other events) in National Parks
- ↳ SANParks' Management Issues
- ↳ General Management Issues - SANParks
- ↳ General Management Issues - Kruger
- ↳ Fire Experiments & Fire Management in KNP
- ↳ Vehicle Accidents in Kruger
- ↳ River Systems & Waterhole Management in KNP
- ↳ General Management Issues - Other National Parks
- ↳ SANParks' Gallery of Shame
- ↳ Ezemvelo KZN Management Issues
- ↳ General Conservation Issues
- ↳ Endangered Species
- ↳ Endangered Ecosystems
- ↳ Hunting
- ↳ Mining and Other Extraction Issues
- ↳ Other Conservation Issues
- ↳ Global Climate Change
- ↳ In the News
- ↳ Park Facilities: Needs Attention
- ↳ Lions and Other Endangered Animals Management and Poaching
- Public Participation - Kruger Management Plan
- ↳ Public Participation - Kruger Management Plan
- Africa Wild Campaigns
- ↳ Africa Wild Causes
- ↳ Petitions Forum
- ↳ World Rhino Day
- ↳ Support Anti Rhino Poaching
- Africa Wild Directory to Game Parks of Southern Africa
- ↳ All you need to know about Game and Bird Spotting
- ↳ All you need to know about South African National Parks
- ↳ South African National Parks in General
- ↳ Kruger National Park
- ↳ Kruger Information & General Discussion Forum
- ↳ Congestion in Kruger
- ↳ Camps of Kruger
- ↳ Favourite Routes in Kruger
- ↳ Gates, Hides, Lookouts & Picnic Spots in Kruger
- ↳ Wilderness and 4x4 Trails
- ↳ Travelling to and from Kruger
- ↳ Fauna and Flora of Kruger Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Kruger
- ↳ History of Kruger
- ↳ Awards Survey
- ↳ Addo Elephant National Park
- ↳ Kgalagadi Transfrontier Park
- ↳ KTP Information and General Discussion Forum
- ↳ Camps of KTP
- ↳ Pics of Creatures Spotted in KTP
- ↳ Travel Tales of KTP
- ↳ Mapungubwe National Park
- ↳ Agulhas National Park
- ↳ Augrabies Falls National Park
- ↳ Namaqua National Park
- ↳ Bontebok National Park
- ↳ Karoo National Park
- ↳ Golden Gate Highlands National Park
- ↳ Camdeboo National Park
- ↳ Garden Route National Park
- ↳ Marakele National Park
- ↳ Mokala National Park
- ↳ Mountain Zebra National Park
- ↳ Table Mountain National Park
- ↳ Tankwa Karoo National Park
- ↳ West Coast National Park
- ↳ Ai-Ais Richtersveld Transfrontier Park
- ↳ All you need to know about Kwa Zulu Natal Game Parks
- ↳ Hluhluwe/Imfolozi Game Reserve
- ↳ Mkuze Game Reserve
- ↳ Ndumo Game Reserve
- ↳ Ithala Game Reserve
- ↳ iSimangaliso Wetland Park
- ↳ Tembe Elephant Park
- ↳ Other KZN Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Travel tales of KZN Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about other South African Game Parks
- ↳ Pilanesberg Game Reserve
- ↳ Gauteng Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ North West Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Limpopo Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Western Cape Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Northern Cape Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Eastern Cape Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Free State Province Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ Mpumalanga Game Parks & Nature Reserves
- ↳ All you need to know about Botswana Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Mozambique Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Namibia Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Eswatini (Swaziland) Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Tanzania Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Zambia Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Malawi Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Zimbabwe Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Kenya Game Parks
- ↳ All you need to know about Uganda Game Parks
- ↳ Questions and discussions on all Southern African Parks
- Africa Wild Travel Tales
- ↳ Africa Wild Travel Tales
- ↳ Travel Tales of South African National Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Kruger National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Kgalagadi Transfrontier National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Addo Elephant National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Mapungubwe National Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of other South African National Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of KZN Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Hluhluwe/Imfolozi Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Ndumo Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Mkuze Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Ithala Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of Tembe Elephant Park
- ↳ Travel Tales of Other KZN Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Other South African Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Pilanesberg Game Reserve
- ↳ Travel Tales of North West Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Limpopo Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Eastern Cape Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Western Cape Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Northern Cape Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Gauteng Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Free State Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Mpumalanga Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Botswana Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Namibia Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Zimbabwe Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Tanzania Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Central & East Africa Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Swaziland Parks
- ↳ Travel Tales of Zambia Parks
- ↳ Tales of Wildlife Experiences & Animal Behaviour
- ↳ Travel Tales of Africa Wild Adventures
- ↳ Travel Tales from around the World
- African Wildlife: Animals, Birds, Plants
- ↳ Mammals
- ↳ Birds
- ↳ Reptiles
- ↳ Amphibians and Fishes
- ↳ Invertebrates
- ↳ Plants
- ↳ The Monthly How, What & Why of Wildlife
- Africa Wild Special Interests
- ↳ Africa Wild Photography
- ↳ Pic of the Day
- ↳ Pic of the Month 2024
- ↳ Pic of the Month 2022/2023
- ↳ Pic of the Year 2023
- ↳ Pic of the Year 2022
- ↳ Pic of the Year 2021
- ↳ Archived Galleries 2011-2024
- ↳ Gallery the Year 2011
- ↳ Bird Pic of the Year 2011
- ↳ Animal Pic of the Year 2011
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2012
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2014
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2015
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2013
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2016
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2017
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2018
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2019
- ↳ Gallery of the Year 2020
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2021
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2022
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2023
- ↳ Gallery of the year 2024
- ↳ General Photography Discussion Forum
- ↳ Technical Photography Discussion Forum
- ↳ Photo Competition - Your Best Photo of.....
- ↳ Webcams
- ↳ Monthly Webcam Gallery
- ↳ Webcam Sightings
- ↳ Africa Wild Quizzies & Games
- ↳ Wildlife from Out of Africa
- ↳ The Fishing Hole
- ↳ Books & Recommended Reading
- ↳ Heritage
- ↳ Natural World
- ↳ Environmental Activists
- Africa Wild Travel and Holiday Information
- ↳ Your Holidays - Responsible Tourism
- ↳ Dongas & Dust
- ↳ Camping
- ↳ Travel Advice and Discussions
- Africa Wild Social Forum
- ↳ The Rhino Midden